Students who can’t concentrate are often asked to turn off the music. A distracted brain is thought to be unable to divide its attention. That advice sounds reasonable.
But new Australian research suggests the advice may be targeting the wrong variables.
Whether background music helps or hinders students has nothing to do with how easily they are distracted. The answer lies somewhere else entirely.
answer simple questions
The study was led by Dr Lindsay Cook from Edith Cowan University (ECU) in Perth, Australia. The team conducted a survey of more than 220 undergraduate students.
The researchers asked intentionally simple questions. Do students play music while reading in class? If so, why?
Previous research on this topic has been pulled in two directions over the years.
Some researchers argue that music depletes the mental resources needed for reading. Some say that the right track can be enough to increase alertness and mood.
Dr. Cook and his co-authors wanted students to self-report their behaviors.
What the students reported
Respondents were almost evenly split. About 54% said they regularly play music while reading, while 46% said they keep quiet.
This ratio alone tells us something. This custom is neither rare nor universal.
Among the music camp, there was almost unanimous agreement on one point.
Almost everyone we listened to believed that music helped them read. No one was doing it thinking it would slow them down.
The reason was practical. Some people used songs to motivate themselves when they felt the textbook was boring. Some asked for help blocking out their roommates and cafe chats.
Several said the music just drew their focus to the page.
Background music with specific functions
Genre preferences were fairly predictable. Classical and rock music topped the list of background music students listened to while reading.
Both of these music genres offer a deep catalog of instrumental tracks that fade into the page.
Within these genres, listeners are drawn to specific features. Most preferred non-lyric tracks – the kind without vocals competing with the words on the page. A slow tempo is better than a fast tempo.
Patterns begin to emerge among these choices. Students aren’t looking for music to entertain them. They want the soundtrack to soften the silence without becoming a second voice, to act more as a buffer than a soundtrack.
Potential underlying factors
Two characteristics have long been thought to be the main explanations for why some students are able to learn using music and others are not.
The first is working memory, the mental scratchpad that holds information while it is processed.
The assumption was simple and straightforward. People who have a spare scratchpad should be able to handle background noise better than people who don’t have the luxury of a scratchpad. Recent research on reading and music lyrics is in that direction.
The second candidate trait was mind wandering, or the tendency to mentally detach in the middle of a task. It was thought that daydreamers would suffer more in either condition.
Dr. Cook’s team measured both traits and looked for associations.
Neither trait predicted anything. Working memory scores could not explain who chose to study with music or who felt distracted by music. So was my tendency to let my thoughts wander.
what was actually predicted
The variable that did emerge was what Dr. Cook’s team calls music engagement, which captures how personally involved someone is with music.
Until this study, no one had pinpointed the separating properties. Previous studies simply asked how music affects cognition.
Dr. Cook’s team asked who must listen to music before it can be helpful.
“While there is a widespread idea that music automatically depletes cognitive resources, our data show that stories are much more personal,” Cook said.
Data shows that listeners’ emotional investment makes background music helpful rather than distracting.
Research limitations and future research
Research can only capture perceptions. Cook’s design relied on self-report, or content that students found useful, rather than actual comprehension scores under controlled conditions.
That gap is the beginning of the next step. The research team plans to test students’ actual understanding in different musical conditions to see if perceived usefulness matches measured performance.
Other studies on attention have shown that music can enhance mood and reduce distractions, suggesting that perception is not purely an illusion.
Still, reading makes special mental demands. What worked there may not carry over to the textbook chapter.
There are also questions that could not be answered by the investigation. Avid listeners may truly benefit from background tracks, or they may simply enjoy the experience so much that they don’t notice the cost.
Both possibilities are real, and research cannot distinguish between them.
helpful questions
What is now clear is that working memory and daydreaming tendencies, which seemed like obvious filters, do not place students into the music camp or the silence camp.
What matters is something more personal: how deeply connected the person is to what they’re listening to.
For tutors and study advisors, a practical point may be to look beyond whether students are studying in music.
This study suggests that people’s overall connection to music may better predict whether background music is helpful or distracting to them.
The research will be published in a journal music psychology.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for fascinating articles, exclusive content and the latest updates.
Check out EarthSnap, a free app from Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–
#music #helps #students #study #distracts